Jim Adler | The Tough, Smart Lawyer
By Jim Adler July 24, 2015

Recent tests by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) highlight front-end crash dangers for four of seven midsize SUVs from the model year 2015. The IIHS, a non-profit insurance industry group, has been conducting these tests annually since 2012 to simulate crash scenarios and ascertain risks for drivers and passengers that may be involved in a front-end collision.

The latest tests involved having 25% of a vehicle’s front end hitting a barrier at 40 miles per hour, comparable to hitting an object such as another vehicle or a utility pole. The institute says its IIHS tests are more demanding of vehicles than the federal government’s own frontal crash tests.

Federal front-end crash tests involve only head-on crashes, in which the vehicle is more equipped to manage crash energy by absorbing it with the main structures of its front-end crush zone. The IIHS’s “small overlap test” of only one-fourth of the vehicle’s front end puts the crash energy in a smaller, more confined space.

Vehicles with limited ability to absorb such small overlap crashes can have their occupant compartment collapse as a result, the IIHS says, causing serious injuries.

By showing automakers inherent front-end collision dangers in their vehicles, the IIHS hopes to encourage redesigns to make them more crash-resistant and safe. The IIHS says manufacturers have responded in two ways since its small overlap testing began in 2012.

First, without making a full overhaul, auto manufacturers have implemented small modifications to enhance their vehicles’ front structure and to improve airbags. Second, when models are redesigned, automakers have taken the tests into account for redesigns.

David Zuby, Chief Research Officer for the IIHS, says Jeep, Dodge and Chrysler “have had some successes” with redesigned models after responding to IIHS test results, but still “haven’t done much in the way of interim improvements.”

Nissan’s redesigned 2015 Murano performs best among current SUVs in providing small overlap crash protection. Its driver space had a maximum intrusion of five inches at the lower door’s hinge pillar, and its side curtain airbag deployed with enough forward coverage to protect a crash test dummy’s head from contacting the side structure or outside objects. The vehicle’s roof strength also was improved.

Dodge Journey Gets Poor Rating

The IIHS ratings range from “poor” to “good.” The worst-performing SUV was Fiat Chrysler’s Dodge Journey, which received a “poor” rating. The IIHS found a passenger compartment did not hold up in a crash, a side airbag did not inflate and its parking brake pedal tore through a crash-test dummy’s lower left leg.

A “good” rating (the highest) went to the Nissan Murano and the Jeep Wrangler four-door, while the Ford Flex was deemed “acceptable,” the second highest rating. The Hyundai Santa Fe, Jeep Cherokee and Dodge Durango all received “marginal” ratings.

The IIHS also awards a “Top Safety Pick Plus” distinction, meaning it received “good” ratings in four crash tests, received a “good” or “acceptable” rating in an overlap test and had a front crash prevention system, designed to brake the vehicle if the vehicle detects a front-end collision is imminent. The Nissan Murano received the distinction in 2015, and the Toyota Highlander received it in 2014. The Chevy Equinox, GMC Terrain, Nissan Pathfinder and Kia Sorento all earned the slightly lower “Top Safety Pick” rating in 2014.

The Ford Flex, which was awarded a “Top Safety Pick” in 2015, lacks the front crash prevention system, which is why it didn’t share in the Pick Plus award. The Jeep Wrangler fell short of the 2015 Pick Plus rating because it had only “marginal” rear- and side-crash protection. It also lacked a fixed roof, the IIHS said, which means its protection would be compromised in an SUV rollover accident.

In response to these tests, Fiat Chrysler pronounced that all of its vehicles meet or exceed federal safety standards. However, the IIHS calls it a “classic example of poor small overlap protection.” Intrusion into the occupant compartment measured as much as nine inches at the instrument panel and at the parking brake pedal, which is why it tore through the crash test dummy’s lower left leg. Also, the side curtain airbag did not deploy, making the dummy’s head vulnerable to contacting outside objects and the side structure.

SUV Rollover Danger

As these crash tests show, Texas drivers in Houston, Dallas, San Antonio and elsewhere should be aware that SUVs can be dangerous beyond driver errors. And one such danger is an SUV rollover.

Not only do these vehicles have front-end crash design defects, as the IIHS study showed, but SUV rollovers are unfortunately common due to the fact that SUVs have a higher center of gravity and a more narrow wheel base than many vehicles. These design flaws contribute to a rollover accident, especially when a driver exceeds safe driving speeds or makes a sudden change in direction.

According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) in 2005, the average SUV involved in a single-vehicle accident was up to two times as likely to roll over compared to a passenger car (23% chance of rollover compared to 10%). To address this potentially devastating situation, the administration also provides its own federal NHTSA ratings specifically for SUV rollovers.

Fortunately, SUV rollover accidents have declined in recent years with the advent of electronic stability control (ESC), a computer system that enhances vehicle control during abrupt moves or moves on a slippery surface. An ESC also helps prevent sideways skids, which can lead to rollovers.

The IIHS says rollovers of vehicles with an ESC “tend to be less severe,” meaning fewer turns. They also often involve initial impacts with other vehicles, which the ESC can’t prevent.

The IIHS concludes that ESC systems reduce the likelihood of fatal single-vehicle rollover crashes by 77-80%. Along with more stable designs, ESC systems have helped reduce rollover fatalities from 27 deaths to 8 deaths per 1 million vehicles that are one to three years old. However, despite these technological advances, design defects and rollovers remain a real threat for many vehicles.

Car Wreck Lawsuit

If a loved one in your home was injured by such a defect in an SUV accident, notify Jim Adler & Associates today for a free case review to explore your legal options for a possible lawsuit.

For 40 years, our personal injury law firm has helped thousands of Texans get payments they were legally due after suffering injuries due to someone else’s negligence. When it comes to auto design defects, that “someone else” is an auto manufacturer.

FREE Case Review
Erick Becker
Erick Becker
01:20 06 May 17
I am a Patrol Deputy for the Sheriff Office and while working one night, a drunk driver crossed the center stripe on the highway and struck my patrol vehicle head on with his pick up truck. Needless to say we (the drunk driver and I) were both lucky to survive, as the accident occurred at highway speeds. Following my release from the hospital, I knew that I would need to have someone represent me. My employer was happy to represent me in regards to prosecuting the driver for criminal charges but, can do little in respect to the recovery of financial losses for medical bills, pain and discomfort, time lost from work etc... This is how my relationship with Jim Adler and Associates began. Yep, you probably guessed correctly when you think of what made me choose the "Texas Hammer" to represent me. Those half obnoxious, half way entertaining commercials and radio announcements most Texans have been seeing and hearing on the TV and radio for years instantly came to mind. Yes, I wanted to "hammer" this S.O.B. for trying to kill me but, more importantly I was worried about the costs associated with the life long injuries I had sustained as a result of this drunk driver's negligent behavior. I contacted Jim Adler and Associates and so began our relationship. I was immediately surprised by the prompt attention and the expression of genuine concern for my well being that I received from the employees of Jim Adler's office. Now as you can imagine, lawyers are not a breed that is held in very high regard by people in my profession but, my experiences with Jim Adler's office and his employees have forced me to amend my way of thinking, at least on the civil side of the house anyway. I have to chuckle when I say that because my experience as a client of Jim Adler's firm has been exceptionally pleasant. So before I venture down one of the stereotypical and infinite number of rabbit holes associated with the relationship between members of law enforcement and lawyers; I will do my best to stay focused on my experience with Jim Adler & Associates. Upon being informed that my case had been accepted by Jim Adler's office; I was contacted by Iris Sanchez who informed me that she was to be my case manager and any questions, comments and concerns could be directed to her. I was pleasantly surprised to receive regular calls from Iris assisting with my medical appointments and future follow up appointments. Iris had informed me that Jim Adler's son, Bill Adler would be handling my case and I was even more surprised to receive several calls from Bill to discuss my case. Now you might be thinking "what's the big deal" with the person who is representing you contacting you? In reality, you are correct in that it isn't a big deal but, what is noteworthy and what separates Jim Adler's Office from the multitude of other lawyers is the genuine expressions of concern and the desire Bill Adler conveyed to me to do their best to help me. I felt an immediate connection and instantly realized I had made the correct choice in contacting Jim Adler & Associates to handle my case. One thing I think lawyers and police officers can agree on is the proverbial wheels of justice turn very slowly. Months go by and our professional relationship is never neglected. Through the unwavering attention of Iris Sanchez and Bill Adler himself, I never felt "out of the loop" so to speak and always had a clear understanding of where my case was at in regards to the legal process. In conclusion, I know my brief description of my experiences with Bill Adler and, his assistant Iris Sanchez, cannot provide the credit they deserve. Together they have done an outstanding job representing their firm/employer. If you are seeking a great firm to represent your legal interests and, take comfort in establishing a professional relationship that feels more like a friendship than a casual business acquaintance, then I highly suggest Jim Adler & Associates.
Tierra Clark
Tierra Clark
18:52 19 May 17
My lawyer Bill Adler and case manager Iris Sanchez are amazing! They constantly call and check on you . They keep you up to date through the process. They care about you as a person and not just a client. The wreck was a life changing experience that I've never been through before. I'm just glad I had the right people like Bill Adler and Iris Sanchez to help me through it. Truly satisfied.Thanks and God bless y'all!
Lorenzo Preston
Lorenzo Preston
17:23 26 Jan 17
Jim Adler only offer nothing less than a great experience. They are a very well-established organization. They are outstanding on keeping you up to date with cases. There's no beating around the bush with this organization as they are only straight forward with the whole process. They treat their customers like family as well as go above and beyond to fight cases for you only leaving you with nothing but the best experience. Easy 5-star rated organization. I would highly recommend this one organization you not look over.
Tori Barroga
Tori Barroga
14:17 11 May 17
I was dropped from a previous law firm regarding my case before I called Jim Adler. They immediately took up my case and worked hard on it - I was always up to date with each step they took and the benefits or consequences of each. In the end, I am highly satisfied with the outcome and would not have it any other way. It took some time but I truly appreciate and want to thank everybody who helped me on this journey and worked tirelessly on it.
Bernard Orozco
Bernard Orozco
17:16 23 Feb 17
I am very happy with Jim Adler & Associates. I did not know anyone who has ever used the Law Firm before. The staff is very friendly and treated me as if I were family. At times it got very stressful being without a job. They helped me when I was confused about the process. Mrs. Theresa Rodriguez stayed in contact with me constantly. Checking on me to see how I was doing and to let me know how things were going on there end. The Attorneys that handled my case know exactly what they are doing to take good care of me. Thank You so much Attorney's Mr.Michael Gomez and Mr.Trey Smith.
See All Reviews
If you’ve been seriously injured, get The Tough, Smart Lawyer! ®
Get Help Right Now
Principal Office Houston, TX